Back to Newsletter

    At what amount does one ETF stop being enough?

    21 October 2026

    Hi,

    You've heard it in almost every video about ETFs. Buy one global fund, an MSCI World or a FTSE All-World, set up a monthly order and you're done.

    Then you read a forum thread where someone with a very serious spreadsheet explains why you should split it: the US in one fund, the rest of the world in another, maybe emerging markets and small caps on top. And the annoying part is that they have a point, because the split can actually earn a little more.

    A client asked me this very question during one of our sessions this month. So who's right?

    Both of them, and what decides it is the size of your portfolio.

    The extra return comes mostly from how the two index families pick their companies. The S&P 500 only admits a company if its last four quarters of earnings add up to a profit and the latest quarter is profitable too. MSCI World takes the large American companies by size, whether they make money or not. You can check the rule yourself, it's written in S&P's own index methodology.

    So how much is that little filter worth to you?

    When I run the numbers, the split buys you something like 0.1% a year of extra expected return. On 50k, that's 50 euros a year. On 100k it's 100 euros, which in Luxembourg is roughly one dinner for two, without the wine.

    In exchange, you now have two or three recurring orders instead of one, several products to follow, and a split between them that drifts every month and that somebody has to put back in place. That somebody is you. And the month you forget, or pause one of the orders "just for a while", you lose more than the dinner you were trying to win.

    Past roughly 200k to 300k, the same 0.1% becomes 200 to 300 euros a year, every year, compounding. At that size an hour of admin a year is well paid, and the extra structure starts to earn its place.

    So before you add a fourth or fifth fund, put a number in euros on what it buys you and compare it with the time it costs. Below about 200k, one global ETF with a monthly order you never touch will usually do better for you than a clever structure you don't maintain.

    I'd like to know where you stand on this. How many ETFs do you hold today, and roughly what's the total? Just reply to this email, I read every reply myself.

    Romain

    The waitlist for the next 7-Day Accelerator is here.

    If your situation needs more than a workshop, you can book a call with me here.


    Get issues like this every week

    One issue per week. Investing and tax insights for Luxembourg.

    Unsubscribe anytime. Your data is processed by Smart Money Growth S.à r.l.-S. See our Privacy Policy for details.