I couldn't answer my own buy versus rent question
Hi,
Back in June, I started looking into buying a place here, and I assumed the hardest part would be finding one.
You'd think that of all people I'd have a clear answer on whether buying even made sense for me. Going through numbers is what I do all week, and I'd already told several people that renting is not the money-burning exercise everyone in Luxembourg says it is. But somehow when it came to answering that same question for myself I realized I was missing the most important piece of the equation, which is understanding what the numbers say.
So I looked for a calculator online. But what did I find?
The issue is, it exists, but NOT for Luxembourg. There's something for the US, the UK, France, and some of it is very good. But nothing works for Luxembourg. Prices are high, which argues for renting. The tax treatment argues the other way, with deductions while you carry the loan, and the employer subsidies. That last part is what none of the calculators could quantify.
And there's one detail that breaks every foreign calculator completely. In most other countries your main residence is exempt and your investments are not, so the comparison leans towards buying before you even start. In Luxembourg both sides are exempt, because your home is tax-free and your ETF gains are tax-free too once you've held them past six months. Renting and investing the difference is a genuinely competitive strategy here in a way it simply isn't elsewhere.
So I looked for a Luxembourg version of this for weeks. Bank sites, broker sites, forum threads. I even used AI to run a deep search. Nothing came out. It simply doesn't exist.
So it took me a week, a long week, and I built it myself.
It compares buying against renting and investing the difference in ETFs, over the horizon you choose. Purchase costs, mortgage interest and what comes back through deductions, maintenance, rent and how fast it rises, and the alternative where you rent and invest the difference instead.
What it gives you is the year where one path overtakes the other, which is usually the only number that matters, because it tells you how long you'd need to stay for buying to have been the right decision.
I made this calculator free. I believe everyone should have that information to make that initial decision of buying vs renting and investing with ETFs. I think it reaches wider than what I teach with ETFs, and everyone should know about it and use it.
What took me a week to work out, anyone can now answer in 30 minutes.
Want to run the numbers for yourself? Click here.
Romain
P.S. It has a lot of parameters, and some of them aren't obvious. If you get a result you didn't expect, or you're not sure what belongs in one of the fields, reply and ask me. I read these myself and the answer is usually one line.