Hi ,
One of the most common questions I get is: "Is one ETF enough? Should I buy
more to be diversified?"
The short answer: the number of ETFs you own tells you almost nothing about how
diversified you are.
Let me show you why.
Imagine you own 10 ETFs. Sounds diversified, right? But what if each one holds
50 stocks, and they are all large-cap US tech companies? You have 10 funds, but
you are basically making one single bet: that American tech keeps going up.
Now imagine someone else owns a single ETF. Just one. But that ETF tracks the
FTSE All-World index. It holds over 4,200 stocks across more than 45 countries,
spanning developed and emerging markets. Every sector. Every region. One fund,
but exposure to the entire global economy.
Who is more diversified?
The person with one ETF. By a wide margin.
This is what professionals call the "look-through" approach. You do not count
the number of funds in your portfolio. You look through to what is actually
inside them. How many individual companies do you own? How many countries? How
many sectors? How many currencies?
The packaging does not matter. The exposure does.
I see this mistake constantly. Someone buys an S&P 500 ETF, then adds a
Nasdaq 100 ETF "for more diversification." But roughly 80% of the Nasdaq 100 is
already in the S&P 500. The top holdings are the same: Apple, Microsoft,
Nvidia, Amazon. You now own two funds, but you have barely added any new
exposure. You just doubled down on the same companies.
Or someone buys three different ETFs from three different providers, all
tracking European large caps. Three funds. One bet.
The question is never "how many ETFs do I own?" The question is: "If I look
through all my holdings, what am I actually exposed to?"
Here is a simple test. Open your portfolio and ask yourself:
- What percentage of my total exposure is in US stocks? (If it is above 80%,
you are heavily concentrated in one country.)
- How many of my top 10 holdings appear in more than one of my ETFs? (If the
answer is most of them, your funds overlap.)
- Do I have any exposure to emerging markets, small caps, or non-tech sectors?
If you cannot answer these questions, you do not know how diversified you are.
And the number of ETFs on your screen is not going to help you figure it out.
One well-chosen global ETF can give you more diversification than a dozen
poorly chosen ones. Simplicity is not the enemy of a good portfolio. Overlap
is.
Talk soon,
Romain