Hi ,
Everyone knows investing involves risk. But almost nobody talks about the fact
that there are two completely different types of risk. And only one of them
pays you.
The first type is called systematic risk. This is the risk of the entire market
going down. A global recession. A financial crisis. A pandemic. When something
like this hits, almost everything drops together. You cannot avoid it by
picking different stocks. It is baked into the system.
This is the risk that gets rewarded. Over the long run, the stock market
compensates you for bearing this risk. That compensation is called the equity
risk premium, and it is the reason why stocks have returned roughly 5% to 7%
above inflation over the past century. You accept that markets will sometimes
crash 30% or 40%. In exchange, you earn returns that no savings account or bond
will ever match.
The second type is called idiosyncratic risk. This is the risk that is specific
to one company, one sector, or one country. A CEO commits fraud. A product
fails. A government changes the rules overnight. If you hold a single stock,
this can wipe you out. Nokia was 70% of the Finnish stock market in 2000. Then
it lost 90% of its value over the next decade.
Here is the critical difference: idiosyncratic risk does not pay you anything.
The market does not reward you for concentrating your bets. This is not an
opinion. It is one of the most established findings in financial economics.
In 1952, Harry Markowitz showed that diversification eliminates idiosyncratic
risk without reducing expected returns. This work earned him the Nobel Prize in
1990. William Sharpe extended it with the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM),
which demonstrated that only systematic risk is priced by the market. If a risk
can be diversified away, the market does not compensate you for taking it.
Fama and French confirmed this empirically across decades of data. The expected
return of a stock is driven by its exposure to broad market factors, not by the
specific risk of that individual company.
In plain language: if you hold one stock instead of a thousand, you are taking
on more risk but not earning higher expected returns. You are just gambling.
This is why someone with a portfolio of 3 individual stocks is not "taking
smart risks." They are taking uncompensated risk. All the volatility, none of
the extra reward.
A diversified global ETF does the opposite. It keeps you exposed to systematic
risk, which is the engine of long-term returns. And it eliminates the
idiosyncratic risk that could blow up your portfolio for no reward.
So yes, take risk. You have to. Without risk, there is no return to achieve
your goals. But make sure it is the right kind. The kind that has paid
investors for over a century. Not the kind that makes for exciting dinner
conversation but has no persistence.
The difference between a good investor and a reckless one is not how much risk
they take. It is which risk they take.
Talk soon,
Romain