Hi ,
The most natural instinct in investing is to look at what did well over the
last few years and buy more of it.
It feels logical. If US tech stocks returned 30% last year, why would you not
just put everything there?
Because the data says that is one of the worst strategies you can follow.
Every year, S&P Dow Jones publishes a report called the Persistence
Scorecard. It tracks whether top-performing funds stay on top. The 2024 edition
found that 0% of US equity funds that were in the top quartile in 2020 remained
in the top quartile over the following four years. Zero. Not a single one.
Of all funds that were in the top half in a given year, only 4.2% managed to
stay in the top half over the next four years. Random chance alone would
predict 6.25%. The actual number was worse than flipping a coin.
This is not just a fund manager problem. It applies to stocks, sectors, and
entire countries.
Look at what happened between the 2000s and the 2010s. Energy stocks were the
dominant sector in the 2000s, rising from about 6% of the S&P 500 to
roughly 15% by 2008. In the 2010s, energy collapsed back down to about 4%.
Emerging markets gained over 200% in the 2000s, then dramatically lagged
throughout the 2010s. Microsoft had a "lost decade" in the 2000s with
essentially zero returns, then surged 545% in the 2010s.
Every single major rotation flipped. Value beat growth in the 2000s. Growth
crushed value in the 2010s. International beat the US in the 2000s. The US
dominated in the 2010s. Seven to nine of the ten largest companies by market
cap get replaced every decade.
Why does this happen? Researchers De Bondt and Thaler studied this in their
famous 1985 paper "Does the Stock Market Overreact?" They found that over
three-year periods, past losers outperformed past winners by an average of
24.6%. Markets overshoot in both directions. What goes up too far tends to come
back down, and what gets beaten down tends to recover.
The Callan Periodic Table of Investment Returns makes this even more visual. It
ranks asset classes from best to worst every year. The pattern is that there is
no pattern. Emerging markets went from the worst performer in 2008 (down 53%)
to essentially the best in 2009 (up 79%). Commodities were number one in 2021
and 2022, then dead last in 2023.
So what does this mean for you?
It means chasing last year's winner is a losing strategy backed by decades of
evidence. It means the sector or country that feels most exciting right now is
probably already overpriced. And it means that the boring, diversified, global
portfolio that never tops any annual ranking is actually the one most likely to
deliver consistent long-term results.
You do not need to pick the winner. You need to own all of them and let time do
the work.
Talk soon,
Romain