What exactly are you paying 1.8% for?
Hi,
By now you probably know that ETFs are cheap and bank mutual funds are expensive.
But did you know the financial institutions selling you a mutual fund at 1.8% a year are the same ones selling you an ETF at 0.2%?
See for yourself. Both of these are BlackRock, and the expensive one is a Luxembourg fund, run from Luxembourg:
BGF World Technology Fund, class A2 EUR (LU0171310443). Ongoing charges 1.80% a year. Initial charge up to 5.00%.
iShares Core MSCI World (IE00B4L5Y983). Total expense ratio 0.20% a year. No entry fee.
So what does that extra 1.6% a year actually buy you?
You might think you're paying for active management, but that doesn't hold up. Active ETFs exist. They're run by real managers making real decisions, and they usually cost well under 1%. If paying professionals to pick stocks genuinely cost 1.8% a year, active ETFs would be priced there too.
So if it's not active management, what are you actually buying?
It goes to distribution and compliance. The branch, the adviser's time, the meetings, the risk profile they're obliged to run before they can sell you anything, the paperwork, and the commission on top. Convincing someone to sign an expensive contract takes hours of expensive people's time, and that cost has to be recovered somewhere.
And you guessed it, you pay for all of it. A 5% entry charge before a single euro is invested, then 1.80% every year after that, calculated on your total wealth and not on your performance.
If you want the cleanest proof that this is distribution rather than management, stay on the same fund. That World Technology fund also has a D2 share class (LU0376438312). Same fund, same manager, same portfolio, same everything. Ongoing charges 1.06% instead of 1.80%, because the management fee drops from 1.50% to 0.75%.
Nothing about the investment changed. The difference is 0.75% a year, and it isn't fund management, since the portfolio is identical. It's the slice built into the retail class that goes back to whoever put you in it.
An ETF carries none of that. Nobody sold it to you, so there's no sales layer to pay for. You decided to buy and the broker executed. The passive structure then adds its own saving, because low turnover means fewer transaction costs inside the fund.
So the real bargain has almost nothing to do with passive versus active. What you're doing when you buy an ETF is taking the decision back. You accept that your money is your job, you learn enough to choose, and you stop paying 1.6% a year to someone who can't possibly have your best interest at heart.
Even when you delegate, you're the one who lives with the result. The fee doesn't change that. It only buys you someone to blame, and by then it's usually too late.
Romain
P.S. If you don't know what your own fund charges you, reply with the name of it and I'll tell you where the real number is written.