Hi,
Private equity has always been that exclusive club you can't get into unless you're very rich. Institutions, pension funds, large family fortunes. It promises double-digit returns at low volatility, which is quite a proposition.
But the doors are opening, and in France it isn't even a choice any more, because since 24 October 2024 the rules require private equity inside managed profiles, starting at 4% in a balanced one. So if you kept a French assurance vie or a PER in gestion pilotée, you already own some without ever having chosen it.
Which raises a question worth two minutes of your time. Why would the most exclusive corner of finance suddenly want your money?
I can sense your skepticism and let me address it right there because as you guessed it it’s not because there’s a great opportunity that just opened to you, quite the opposite.
The answer is that the professionals can't get out.
Private equity funds buy companies, improve them for five to seven years, then sell them and return the cash. That worked beautifully while debt was almost free and buyers kept paying higher and higher multiples. Since 2022 an acquirer borrows at 5% or 6% instead of 1%, so nobody will pay 2021 prices, and the sellers refuse to mark their holdings down to what the market offers. Nobody agrees, so almost nothing sells.
You can see it in what is not being sold. According to Bain, roughly 32,000 companies are still waiting for a buyer, worth 3.8 trillion dollars between them. Funds that should have wound up at ten years keep running past it, charging their fees the whole time.
That doesn't mean the companies are worthless. It means the exit is late, and a late exit ends up destroying the return. Doubling your money in five years is close to 15% a year. The same doubling stretched over ten years is 7%. Same gain, half the return, purely because the sale dragged.
The industry has found ways to keep things moving. Just under half of European exit value last year came from selling to another private equity fund rather than to an industrial buyer or the stock market, and in the first quarter of this year that share hit 76%. Continuation funds go further, where the manager sets up a new fund to buy the companies out of his own old fund, so he's on both sides of the trade and keeps charging fees afterwards. The US regulator has opened an inquiry into those structures. European volumes doubled last year.
The secondary market is where you see the honest price, because that's where fund stakes actually change hands. Last year the average portfolio of fund stakes changed hands at 87% of its stated value. Your statement says 100 and the buyer pays 87.
And the products being sold to savers are usually evergreen structures, with no end date and regular redemption windows. You get promised a liquid holding built on assets that aren't liquid, which works while money keeps coming in. It already happened this year, in private credit rather than private equity. In the first quarter investors in one of Blue Owl's largest credit funds asked to withdraw 21.9% of it and were allowed 5%. At that rate a full exit takes more than a year, and that assumes nobody else asks.
I'm not predicting a collapse, and this is nothing like 2008. The likely outcome is a long sorting process where weak managers fail to raise, mediocre assets change hands at a discount, and the sector concentrates around the big names. Private equity isn't dead, but the easy version of it is.
If someone pitches you a private markets fund, there are five things worth checking before you sign. Ask for the DPI of the manager's previous funds, which is the cash actually returned against the cash put in rather than the paper valuation. Check whether his past funds respected the life they announced. Read the real exit conditions in the fund rules and not in the brochure. Add up the total fees, the fund's and the wrapper's together, which often pass 3%. And only commit money you won't need, because even an evergreen fund can close the door.
This is also why I keep coming back to listed markets for the core of a portfolio. A public price is set by real buyers and sellers every single day, so it's rarely far from the truth. A private valuation is an opinion until somebody actually pays it.
Romain
P.S. The next events are announced in the Community WhatsApp first, join it if you haven’t yet https://whatsapp.smoney.lu