Hi ,
You followed the evidence. You invested in a diversified global ETF. You did
not try to time the market. You kept your fees low. You did everything right.
Then the market dropped 15% and your friend who bought Bitcoin doubled his
money.
So you start wondering: did I make the wrong decision?
No. You are falling into a trap that poker champion and decision scientist
Annie Duke calls "resulting."
Resulting is when you judge the quality of a decision by the outcome it
produced. It sounds logical. Good decision, good outcome. Bad decision, bad
outcome. But in any situation involving uncertainty, this logic falls apart.
A poker player who goes all-in with pocket aces is making the right decision.
If they lose to a lucky river card, it does not mean they played wrong. It
means the outcome did not match the probabilities this time. Over hundreds of
hands, that same decision will win far more than it loses.
Investing works the same way.
Your friend who bought Bitcoin and doubled his money made a high-risk,
concentrated bet that happened to work. Does that mean it was a good decision?
If he put 50% of his net worth into a single volatile asset with no fundamental
valuation framework, the answer is no. He got lucky. The same decision made by
a thousand people will produce a few spectacular winners and many painful
losers.
Your diversified portfolio that dropped 15% was the right decision. The
expected outcome over 10, 20, 30 years is strongly positive. One bad quarter
does not change the math.
But our brains are wired to evaluate decisions by results. We cannot help it.
When we see someone else's risky bet pay off, we feel like we missed out. When
our careful plan has a bad stretch, we feel like we were wrong.
The fix is to separate the decision from the outcome.
Ask yourself: based on what I knew at the time, was this the best decision I
could make? Was it supported by evidence? Was it consistent with my goals and
time horizon?
If the answer is yes, the outcome does not change anything. Good process,
applied consistently, wins over time. Not every time. Over time.
The danger is changing a good process because of a bad result. That is how
people abandon smart strategies and start chasing whatever worked last quarter.
And that is how they end up worse off than if they had just stayed the course.
Trust the process. Let the results take care of themselves.
Talk soon,
Romain